Boomerang Books Info Bank

http://www.boomerangbooks.com.au/content/book-reviews/audio-book-reviews/ice-station-reilly-audio.shtml

Audio Book: Ice Station by Matthew Reilly, read by Sean Mangan

I suppose it’s appropriate for Reilly’s adventure, set in a US-run scientific base in Antarctica, to be read in an American (actually, a Canadian) accent. Nonetheless, it’s initially a little off-putting for an Australian production of an Australian novel. Sean Mangan’s reading is well-paced, if a little flat and ‘radio announcer’ in tone at first.

I suppose it’s appropriate for Reilly’s adventure, set in a US-run scientific base in Antarctica, to be read in an American (actually, a Canadian) accent. Nonetheless, it’s initially a little off-putting for an Australian production of an Australian novel. Sean Mangan’s reading is well-paced, if a little flat and ‘radio announcer’ in tone at first.

Ice Station (Matthew Reilly, read by Sean Mangan, $24.95, 1xMP3-CD, ISBN 1740948874) ***

I suppose it’s appropriate for Reilly’s adventure, set in a US-run scientific base in Antarctica, to be read in an American (actually, a Canadian) accent. Nonetheless, it’s initially a little off-putting for an Australian production of an Australian novel. Sean Mangan’s reading is well-paced, if a little flat and ‘radio announcer’ in tone at first. As the plot develops and the action begins, Mangan’s reading comes to life, although in some dialogue-heavy action sequences he does get a little shouty. Reilly has earned an enviable reputation in the last few years for his action-filled, page-turning high-tech thrillers. Many of his readers are apparently young men in their teens and 20s, often otherwise reluctant readers who may not have read a book since school. I wonder how many of those sort of readers would have the patience—or even the opportunity—to listen to over 15 hours of audio book? The question of abridgement is a difficult one in the world of audio books, but in this case, I suspect that a much shorter rendition could have been more effective. And with the amount of mayhem, death and explosions being described, perhaps some sound effects would come in handy?

Tim Coronel is AB&P’s editor

This review from Australian Bookseller & Publisher magazine is reproduced by kind permission of Thorpe-Bowker, a division of R R Bowker LLC. © Copyright 2005, Thorpe-Bowker