Dissection (Jacinta Halloran, Scribe, $27.95 tpb, ISBN 9781921372124, July) ** 1/2
Dissection is a skillfully written piece of work that charts the despair of a woman, a doctor, who begins to question her ability to function both professionally and personally. Dr Anna McBride has a malpractice suit hanging over her head and a husband who is clearly having an affair with a younger woman. Anna begins to question and dissect herself in the desperation of failing to do what is expected of her both as a doctor and as a wife and mother. Halloran carefully layers Anna’s anguish regarding all aspects of her life and crafts some beautifully written studies. However, Anna’s desperation is so overwhelming that eventually her meditations become ponderous and exhausting. As Anna clinically defines her failures, one after the other, the reader becomes aware that the novel is ultimately bleak and it requires a certain stoicism to simply keep reading. The story unremittingly contemplates Anna’s inability to trust herself to be what she is supposed to be, and as such becomes brooding and uninteresting as there are only so many ways to read about her insecurity before becoming disinterested in both her and her plight. This novel may be best recommended to those who read literary fiction and may find the novel stylistically sophisticated.
Nadine Whitney is an ex-bookseller and currently a teacher
This review from Australian Bookseller & Publisher magazine is reproduced by kind permission of Thorpe-Bowker, a division of R R Bowker LLC. © Copyright 2008, Thorpe-Bowker
Tags:
jacinta halloran
Wanting by Richard FlanaganRichard Flanagan’s fourth novel is set in his native Tasmania, and returns to the troubled early history of the colony in the mid 19th century.
1 October, 2008
Lemniscate by Gaynor McGrathAn odd title (which refers to the infinity symbol) and 50 or so pages of stilted, naive dialogue and irritating moralising, did not make me want to continue reading this novel.
1 October, 2008
In Bed With by Adams JessicaPeople will buy this collection of erotic short stories, because of the author names they are familiar with.
1 October, 2008
Grace Notes by Jenny PattrickGrace Notes by Jenny Pattrick is a lively read, with well-rounded characters, feisty dialogue and excellent sense of location.
1 October, 2008
The Best of Australian Poetry 2008 by David BrooksIt’s the sixth year of UQP’s ‘Best Australian Poetry’ series, and guest editor David Brooks, whose recent novel was shortlisted for the 2008 Miles Franklin award, invites us to once again sample the cream of contemporary Australian poetry.
1 October, 2008
The Art of Graeme Base by Julie WattsLike a child reading Animalia for the first time I devoured this illustrated biography of a talented and fortunate man in one extended reading and then went back to examine choice pages.
1 October, 2008
The Independence of Miss Mary Bennet By Colleen McCulloughAccording to a recent poll of 15,000 Dymocks booklover members, Pride and Prejudice is considered one of the best books ever written and yet one that I am shamefaced to admit has never quite made it to the top of my reading pile.
1 September, 2008
The Edge of Desire by Stephanie LaurensIf you’ve read Laurens’ ‘Bastion Club’ series you’ll find Edge of Desire similar to the previous seven books.
1 September, 2008
Vertigo by Amanda LohreyWith the novella Vertigo, award-winning author Amanda Lohrey (The Philosopher’s Doll, Camille’s Bread) once more taps into the Australian zeitgeist.
1 September, 2008
The Slap by Christos TsiolkasThe Slap’s action hinges around a Melbourne suburban BBQ.
1 September, 2008
Comments
1 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.
I finished this book in one sitting - so unputdownable it was. As a trainee GP myself, it echoed on several occasions how I have felt about my professional experiences do far. I'd make it compulsory reading for any non-doctor. It would hopefully convey to them the fact that doctors are human beings with their own problems. Hopefully it would encourage patients to be more reasonable in their expectations and less self centred and to appreciate that doctors do try their best for them. When we do make mistakes, our consciences are troubled. There is a limit to how much we can take responsibility for other peoples' problems. We are not teflon coated robots with magic wands!
Add a Comment
Please be civil.