Families Behind Bars (Kay Danes, New Holland, $29.95 pb, ISBN 9781741106466, May) ***
Kay Danes, an Australian who was falsely arrested and detained for gem theft in Laos, has told her horrific battle of endurance in her previous book Deliver Us from Evil. Now a prominent social justice ambassador, in this new book she delves deeper to disclose the sufferings and strength of others detained in foreign prisons and the stories of their family’s struggles. Danes has an authoritative voice filled with passion, and she has a personal involvement in many of the cases in the book, which include those of Schapelle Corby and the Bali 9. The aims of the book are obvious as she says she wishes to use her experiences ‘to help create awareness about injustice, social issues, personal safety and overcoming adversity.’ However, the book’s heavy early focus on the legalities of detainment, written in a clinical, bureaucratic voice, affects its readability, as we don’t connect emotionally with the information. There are so many short stories with so few details, readers are swamped, and it’s hard to build empathy. The audience the book would most appeal to is those in a similar ituation of detainment and their families; this is made very evident by the constant advice for ‘other families’ mentioned throughout.
Lucy Meredith is a casual bookseller for Angus and Robertson and a freelance writer
This review from Australian Bookseller & Publisher magazine is reproduced by kind permission of Thorpe-Bowker, a division of R R Bowker LLC. © Copyright 2008, Thorpe-Bowker
Tags:
kay danes
The Four Hour Workweek by Timothy FerrissI’ve just started reading Timothy Ferriss’ award-winning book,
The Four Hour Work Week, and have already started to adopt some of his philosophies.
17 September, 2008
Trains and Railways of Australia by Jim PoweJim Powe presents a unique photographic collection, most of which is published for the first time.
1 September, 2008
Inside Out by Gideon HaighA cricket fan’s dream and a learner’s manual rolled into one, Inside Out brings together Gideon Haigh’s colourful, poignant and suitably smart-mouthed despatches from the crease.
1 September, 2008
1000 Best-ever Recipes of the Australian Women's Weekly by Australian Women's WeeklyI’ve always seen the AWW as slightly staid and unfashionable; however, this hefty, encyclopaedic cookbook has certainly challenged this view.
1 September, 2008
Turning Points in Australian History by Martin Crotty & David RobertsFollowing on from their previous book, The Great Mistakes of Australian History, Crotty and Roberts once again assemble notable Australian historians and thinkers to dissect key events in our past.
1 September, 2008
Superstitions: Beliefs, Rituals and Magic by Xavier WaterkynIt’s an ambitious task to cover such a comprehensive range of topics and perhaps herein lies the problem, as I found this compilation somewhat disjointed.
1 September, 2008
Translating Lives by Mary Besemeres & Anna Wierzbicka *Through the stories of 12 people living in Australia, Translating Lives examines the multicultural experience with a particular focus on what it means to speak more than one language.
1 September, 2008
Brush with Gondwana by Janda GoodingBrush with Gondwana is unique because it’s one of the first books in this genre I’ve come across that celebrates the artistic achievements of the Botanical Artists’ Group of WA (BAG), a group that formed (loosely) over a pot of tea in 1992.
1 September, 2008
Mr Darwin's Incredible Shrinking World by Peter MacinnisA barrage of information comes at the reader who chooses to tackle Mr Darwin’s Incredible Shrinking World.
1 September, 2008
Layne Beachley by Michael Gordon & Layne BeachleyConceived through rape and adopted out, the tomboyish, small-statured champion surfer Layne Beachley had, from the outset, a deep-seated motivation for succeeding: ‘When Dad told me I was adopted, that was when I decided I was going to be the best in the world at something, anything... because that would earn me the love and respect of someone.’
1 September, 2008
Comments
1 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.
I have to disagree with Lucy Meredith in her review of this book. I was given a copy by a friend and I found many of the stories to be quite horrifying. I have been a strong supporter of the Aggett family. Jody spent six years in the Bangkok prison for a crime he didn't commit. He was finally aquitted but the pain his family went through was unimaginable. Kay included their story in the book and it really hit home to me just how fragile our lives are. I think Meredith should go and read it again. If she thinks it didn't have emotion in it then I can't understand what sort of person she is. Perhaps she is too hardened as a journalist to see the pain that Kay's writing was revealing. I imagine that she didn't want to over expose the families and actually it was good that Kay didn't over dramatise the stories as most writers do. We live in a country that provides great opportunities for all but my God, who would ever believe that half this stuff actuall happens. Great book! Well worth reading.
Add a Comment
Please be civil.